back
ID3
Title Tampering with birth dates should occur morer often among rural than urban people. Scrutiny of Geoffrey Dean's paretal tampering claim (1)
Author Ertel, Prof. Suitbert
Address Georg-August-Universitat, Georg-Elias-Muller-Institut fur Psychologie, Division Personality and Psychological Diagnostics, Gossler Strasse 14, D-37073, Goettingen, Germany.
WebSite
Publication Correlation: Astrological Association Journal of Research In Astrology
Issue Volume 19, Issue 2
Date 2000/2001
Pages pages 37-46
Keywords Dean, Gauquelin, parental tampering
Abstract
Geoffrey Dean claims that parents of Gauquelin professionals, guided by superstition, tampered with birth dates and birth times of their children when they gave their obligatory reports at registration offices (Dean, 2000). In his view, therefore, Gauquelin planetary effects might be "man made" to a large extent, or even entirely, due to the parents' efforts to enhance their children's fortunes and to banish possible misfortune . Dean used four "avoidance" variables (unlucky day avoidance, new Moon avoidance etc) and four "preference" variables (lucky day preference, full Moon preference etc.) as superstition indicators. I tested the validity of these variables by dividing the French Gauquelin professionals N= 7,952) into seven sub-samples of equal size sorted by birth place population. Dean's avoidance and preference indicators should be more pronounced in rural (small population) compared with urban samples (large population) because popular beliefs flourish in rural life while fading away with urbanization. The indicators did not show the expected decline across samples from urban to rural birth places. This result casts considerable doubt on Dean's alleged superstition variables upon which his enterprise is grounded.


Order a complete photocopy of the article:
Tampering with birth dates should occur morer often among rural than urban people. Scrutiny of Geoffrey Dean's paretal tampering claim (1)

The RGCSA has an agreement with the AA, the publishers of the research Journal Correlation, to make articles contained in the journal available by request and on observation of copyright rules. If you wish to request full copies of any of the abstracted articles from Correlation contained on the RGCSA database you can do so by completing and returning, with payment, the articles request form. This form should be completed and downloaded so that you may sign the copyright declaration contained within it. When the AA has received this form, with your signature, together with payment, the article will then be despatched to you, normally within fourteen days of receiving your request. For copyright reasons you must sign the form and return it before a copy of the article can be released to you. UK copyright law currently insists on actual signatures so an electronically mailed signature is not acceptable. We look forward to receiving your requests and hope that you will enjoy this new service.

 

© 2009 Research Grants for the Critical Study of Astrology